Politics

Fact-Checking the Sunday Shows: Jan. 24

SAY WHAT?

Did Trump actually say global warming was a Chinese hoax, and is Ted Cruz’s attack ad on him accurate?

articles/2016/01/24/fact-checking-the-sunday-shows-january-24/160124-tdb-pundits-tease_joymeo
Photo Illustration by The Daily Beast

By Katie Sanders, Lauren Carroll and Louis Jacobson

With the days before the Iowa caucuses finally reaching single digits, presidential candidates weighed in on a possible surprise bid from billionaire and former New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg.

The New York Times reported Saturday that Bloomberg, an independent, is considering a wild-card run after seeing the rise of Donald Trump and Texas Sen. Ted Cruz on the right and the problems of Hillary Clinton’s campaign on the left.

ADVERTISEMENT

Clinton said on NBC’s Meet the Press that she plans to get the Democratic presidential nomination, “so he doesn’t have to.” Her rising Democratic rival, Sen. Bernie Sanders, said a “contest between billionaires” Bloomberg and Trump would bolster his case as the only candidate looking out for the middle class.

Trump, on CBS’s Face the Nation, said he “would love” the chance to run against Bloomberg because “he’s very opposite on me with guns, and he’s opposite on pro-life and he’s opposite on a lot of things.”

Trump may have had tame words for Bloomberg, but he had a whole lot more to say about Texas Sen. Ted Cruz, his chief Republican competition in Iowa, who attacked Trump in a new attack ad. Meet the Press host Chuck Todd played the ad, which says Trump loves eminent domain because it “made him rich, like when he colluded with Atlantic City insiders to bulldoze the home of an elderly widow.”

Trump wasted no time attacking the ad Sunday on NBC’s Meet the Press.

“I have to tell you his ad, is wrong, because I never knocked down that house,” Trump said. “I wanted to get that house to build a major building that would have employed tremendous numbers of people, but then the woman didn’t want to sell, ultimately I just said, ‘Forget about it.’ So he’s got me bulldozing down a house, I never bulldozed it down. It’s false advertising.”

Todd said, “Well, all right, the accusation was that that’s what you wanted to do.” But Trump stood by his takedown, saying, “No, the accusation was that I did it, and I didn’t do it.”

We rate the claim Half True.

Cruz’s ad references a period in the 1990s, prior to a Supreme Court deciding eminent domain could be applied to private commercial development as well as public projects.

Trump planned to build a limousine garage to service the Trump Plaza Hotel and Casino in Atlantic City, N.J., but several pieces of private property were in the way, including a home owned since the 1960s by a widow in her late 60s named Vera Coking. Trump has said he offered Coking millions for her property, but she wouldn’t give up her home. In 1994, New Jersey’s Casino Reinvestment Development Authority threatened to use eminent domain to seize the house.

The dispute ended up in front of the New Jersey Superior Court, which ruled against Trump and the government in 1998. After losing the case, Trump gave up his plan to buy Coking’s house, telling the New York Daily News that he was "no longer an interested buyer."

Both Cruz and Trump are stretching the truth about what happened with a widow’s home. But Trump’s assertion that Cruz “has got me bulldozing down a house, I never bulldozed it down” omits that Cruz’s ad can be interpreted more accurately than Trump acknowledges.

Trump and the ‘Chinese hoax’ of climate change

Speaking of Trump attacks, Democratic candidate and Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders cited poll numbers and Trump’s unsavory positions on liberal issues, like raising the minimum wage and climate change, to make the case that he could take Trump in the general election.

“I would very much look forward to a race against Donald Trump, adding that Trump is someone who “thinks that climate change is a hoax, invented by the Chinese,” Sanders said on Meet the Press.

Does Trump blame the Chinese for inventing the hoax of climate change? Sanders’s claim rates Mostly True.

The clearest example comes from a tweet Trump sent Nov. 6, 2012. “The concept of global warming was created by and for the Chinese in order to make U.S. manufacturing non-competitive.”

That certainly gives Sanders some ammo. Trump has somewhat backed off of this tweet, calling the Chinese link a “joke” on Fox & Friends the day after Sanders attacked Trump’s climate-change views in the Democratic debate.

“Well, I think the climate change is just a very, very expensive form of tax. A lot of people are making a lot of money,” Trump said. “And I often joke that this is done for the benefit of China. Obviously, I joke. But this is done for the benefit of China, because China does not do anything to help climate change. They burn everything you could burn; they couldn’t care less.”

He may claim he was joking about the Chinese inventing climate change. But Trump has repeatedly called climate change a “hoax” in speeches, tweets and media appearances, and while he hasn’t repeated the charge that China “invented” climate change, he has said that China benefits when the rest of the world takes steps to curb climate change.

For the record, in 2014 we rated the claim that climate change is a “hoax” Pants on Fire.

These fact-checks have been edited for print. For full fact-checks, go to PunditFact.com.

-----------------------------------------------------------

Got a tip? Send it to The Daily Beast here.